
Data center backlash: will France follow the US midterms?
AI data centers swayed the US midterms: 76% of voters oppose one in their community. France has the power the US lacks, yet its own backlash has already begun.
AI data centers have become an election issue. In the US midterm elections of November 3, 2026, 56% of voters said AI and data centers were a "crucial" or "major" factor in their vote, according to the exit poll published by NBC, and 76% oppose building a data center in their community. The same day, voters sided against data centers in 40 out of 41 local ballot measures.
The American backlash is first and foremost about the electricity bill. In March, 72% of data center opponents cited the cost of electricity, ahead of water and noise, and on the grid that serves the eastern US, data centers added $6.27 billion to the cost of the latest capacity auction. Right after the vote, more than 100 organizations called for a moratorium on large data centers in Europe, France included.
France will not replay this scenario as is: it generates 95.2% of its electricity without carbon and exported a record 92.3 TWh in 2025. It has a backlash of its own all the same. It is about farmland, fast-tracked procedures and a question American voters do not ask: who are these data centers being built for? That question will decide whether France follows, and it directly concerns every company that buys AI.
Why did AI data centers matter in the midterms?
An AI data center is a building full of servers fitted with graphics processors (GPUs), which train models and answer users' requests. Its power is counted in hundreds of megawatts: the campus planned in Fouju, east of Paris, is set to reach 1.4 GW at full capacity. In the United States, these projects have multiplied faster than the power plants needed to supply them: on the eastern grid, the latest auction cleared only 525 MW of new generation and uprates.
The electricity bill, the main driver
The average residential electricity price in the US rose from 17.03 to 18.19 cents per kilowatt-hour between the first eight months of 2025 and the same period of 2026, a 6.8% increase. The federal Energy Information Administration does not attribute the rise to data centers. Voters made the connection anyway.
The best-documented case is PJM, the operator of the grid that serves thirteen eastern states. Every year, PJM buys in advance the generating capacity needed to cover peak demand, and that cost ends up on bills. At the latest auction, in July, the price hit its cap and the grid was 6,831 MW short of its reliability requirement, for the second year running. The independent market monitor did the math: "There would have been no shortfall but for the forecast data center load." Without data centers, there would have been no shortfall. Their arrival cost $6.27 billion in this auction and $29.4 billion over the last four.
Next come water, cited by 64% of opponents, noise (41%) and tax breaks: Georgia, Virginia and Texas each report losing at least $1 billion a year in data center incentives.
What voters decided
The issue moved votes. Among voters who called AI and data centers decisive, 65% voted Democratic; among those for whom it mattered little, 56% voted Republican. Yet opposition is not partisan: in September, 55% of Republican voters opposed an AI data center in their community, against 85% of Democrats.
The local vote was clear-cut. Of the 41 local measures on November 3, 27 restrictive measures passed, including 5 full bans, 12 partial bans and 3 six-month moratoriums, and all 13 measures favorable to data centers failed. Among newly elected governors, 32 out of 34 support regulation or conditional development, 12 of them a ban or a moratorium, according to Data Center Watch.
Some states did not wait for the election. In Texas, Republican governor Greg Abbott halted all permits sought by data centers in September, pending a grid audit. New York launched the first statewide moratorium on new hyperscale data centers in July.
Washington wants data centers to pay for their power
Bernie Sanders is calling for a "National data center moratorium now", and a bill to that effect was introduced in the House by Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez in June. On November 11, Josh Hawley became the first Republican senator to back a national moratorium. The new Congress will not sit until January, and Donald Trump keeps his veto: we think a federal moratorium is unlikely.
The consensus is forming elsewhere. On November 9, the White House backed a bipartisan bill, writing that "the costs of serving hyperscale load must be borne by those who cause them", not by households and small businesses. Republicans and Democrats now agree on one thing: data centers should pay for their own electricity. Several states have already created separate rates or terms for large consumers: New Jersey in July, Delaware in August, Oklahoma in the spring.
Markets reacted two days later
On November 5, the Nasdaq-100 fell 6.36%, its worst session since March 2020. Morgan Stanley, quoted by AP, warned that restrictions could "split the country into areas that are open to new data centers and those without". According to the firm Cleanview, about 40% of planned capacity sits in states whose new governor has promised a halt or a pause.
Is France facing the same backlash against data centers?
Yes, and it showed the very week of the midterms. On November 6 and 7, the European "Stop Dirty Data Centres" campaign listed actions in Loon-Plage, Fouju, Rungis, Marseille and Paris, as part of a mobilization in about fifteen European countries. France Nature Environnement, a federation of environmental groups, took part: "what we are asking for is an immediate moratorium until public authorities define the needs", its spokesperson Maxime Colin told franceinfo.
The largest projects are being challenged. In Fouju, the campus backed by MGX, Nvidia, Mistral AI and Bpifrance covers 89 hectares; a petition has gathered more than 47,000 signatures and six legal challenges target its permit. Near Châteauroux, in central France, the site of what would be Google's first wholly owned data center in the country covers 195 hectares, and RTE plans about 90 km of power lines for the area. Near Valence, the Grenoble administrative court suspended a data center permit for lack of an impact study. In Wissous, south of Paris, local groups accused the operator of splitting its project into 19.8 MW and 49.5 MW phases to stay under the 50 MW threshold above which a full impact study and a public inquiry are required; the administrative court of appeal dismissed their case.
So France has its backlash. It almost never mentions the bill.
Why the French backlash differs from the American one
A data center in France meets the same objections as in the United States, except one: the French grid is not short of power, so opponents look for their arguments elsewhere.
France is not short of electricity
In 2025, France generated 547.5 TWh against consumption of 451 TWh, exported a record 92.3 TWh and saw 513 hours of negative prices, when producers pay to offload their power. Data centers connected to the transmission grid consumed close to 1 TWh, plus 3 TWh on Enedis's distribution grid in 2024. The energy regulator CRE proposed flat regulated household tariffs on February 1, 2026. The American driver of the backlash, the bill, does not run in France. Anne Le Hénanff, the minister in charge of AI and digital affairs, put it this way on November 9: "to date, there is no competing demand".
Grid connection is the scarce resource
What is scarce is room on the grid. By late November 2025, RTE had already granted 14 GW of transmission access rights to data centers, and the government counted 28.6 GW of power being sought. These reservations overstate actual consumption: according to RTE, data centers already connected use only 20% of their contracted capacity. Hence the reform of the connection queue, which the minister sums up as "what counts is not who comes first, but who is ready."
RTE expects data centers on dedicated sites to consume between 21 and nearly 32 TWh in 2035 depending on the pace of decarbonization, or 5 to 7% of the country's current consumption. For its stagnation scenario, RTE lists "local moratorium policies" among the possible explanations.
Water: a debate without full numbers
Water mobilizes campaigners, but nobody measures all of it. The telecoms regulator Arcep counted 575,000 m³ withdrawn in 2024, down 15%, for colocation operators only; hyperscalers (Amazon, Google, Microsoft) will only enter its survey in the 2027 edition. The government speaks of 0.002% of water withdrawals; opponents put forward other figures. As long as the largest consumers publish nothing, the debate will remain a matter of trust.
Land and process
Giant projects need tens, sometimes hundreds of hectares, often farmland. To speed them up, a 2026 simplification law allows them to be designated "projects of major national interest." The Constitutional Council upheld the measure, specifying that the designation has "neither the purpose nor the effect of changing the substantive conditions" of permits: it speeds up changes to zoning documents, not environmental review. Opponents still see it as a way around local debate, hence the growing number of lawsuits. In France, the backlash goes through the courts, not the ballot box.
Who is it built for?
This is where France stands apart. In July, a National Assembly inquiry into digital dependencies recommended a moratorium on non-European data centers. In October, left-wing MPs took up its finding that the government is "throwing the door wide open to a rapid lock-in of the artificial intelligence market by the largest American players" in a draft resolution for a five-year moratorium on "non-sovereign data centers, run by non-European players." The minister herself answers on that ground: "we want to develop data centers, but not any old way, and not with just anyone".
In the United States, the debate is about the bill; hardly anyone asks who owns the building. In France, people first ask who the building serves.
| United States | France | |
|---|---|---|
| Power grid | Short on the PJM grid (6,831 MW) | In surplus: 92.3 TWh exported in 2025 |
| Opponents' main concern | The cost of electricity | Land, process, sovereignty |
| Where the backlash plays out | At the ballot box: local measures, governors, Congress | In court and in Parliament: lawsuits, petitions, resolutions |
| Public response | State moratoriums and suspensions, separate rates | Fast-tracked projects, a tax break to be made conditional |
Could France tip into the American scenario?
Europe shows that electricity can become the issue. In Ireland, data centers consumed 23% of metered electricity in 2025, up from 5% in 2015. Since 2021, the regulator's connection criteria have created what the law firm William Fry calls a "de facto data centre connection moratorium"; a new data center above 10 MVA must now bring its own dispatchable generation or storage. In Finland, the environmental regulator ordered a Google subsidiary in October to suspend preparatory work at two sites while it checks whether more than 300 hectares of forest were cleared without the mandatory impact assessment.
France is far from that, and politics is moving the other way. A Senate committee rejected "any idea of a moratorium" in a report adopted unanimously in September, and the European Commission wants to at least triple the EU's data center capacity within five to seven years. Even in the US, State Street expects that AI investment "will likely continue to be robust in 2027", and Data Center Watch points out that campaign promises do not automatically become policy.
We do not believe in a general moratorium in France in the short term. We do see three conditions that would bring France closer to the American scenario: reservations that turn into actual consumption, a tax break seen as a giveaway (data centers' electricity benefits from a reduced excise rate, which the government wants to make conditional on environmental performance), and procedures that leave local residents with no say. Which projects are accepted and which are refused will be decided on "who is it for?" long before the kilowatt-hour.
What a French company should take away
A company that uses AI does not build data centers, but it depends on other people's, and therefore on these debates, more than it may think.
- US computing capacity is becoming a political variable. An AI provider whose models run in the United States now depends on decisions made in Texas, Ohio or Georgia. The 40% of planned capacity located in states that promise a pause will not disappear, but it will come later, elsewhere or at a higher cost.
- The cost of electricity will weigh more on data centers. That is now the White House's position as well as the Democrats'. Part of that cost will end up in the price of AI services: this is our reading, not a measured fact. It will not be enough to make AI more expensive for the same service, as we explain in our article on the AI inflation illusion.
- Where models are hosted is once again a vendor choice. Hosting in France does not carry the same political risk, but the French debate targets non-European operators precisely. Choosing where your models run also means choosing which side of the debate you are on. We cover the criteria for sovereign AI, the risks of dependence on American providers and what a French player such as OVHcloud offers.
- The least contested computing is the computing you do not use. Many automations need neither a large model nor AI at all: when a task is deterministic, a classic algorithm is more reliable and more frugal, as we argue in our article on automation. When AI is needed, a well-chosen mid-size model is often enough.
- Provider figures are worth asking for. Server location, electricity, water: even Arcep does not yet have the hyperscalers' data. A company that asks for them in its tenders will be better prepared the day these numbers become a public issue.
Frequently asked questions about the data center backlash
Why do Americans oppose AI data centers?
Mainly because of their electricity bill. According to Quinnipiac University, 72% of data center opponents cited the cost of electricity in March 2026, 64% water and 41% noise. On the PJM grid, which serves thirteen eastern states, the independent market monitor estimates that data centers added $6.27 billion to the cost of the latest capacity auction. In the November 3, 2026 exit poll, 76% of voters opposed a new data center in their community.
What is a data center moratorium?
It is a pause on approving or building new data centers, usually above a certain size, while rules are set. New York State launched in July 2026 a moratorium of up to one year on environmental permits for hyperscale data centers, and Texas halted in September all permits sought by data centers until an audit of its grid is complete. In Europe, the "Stop Dirty Data Centres" campaign calls for an immediate moratorium on large projects, without a specific threshold or duration.
How much electricity do data centers use in France?
According to RTE, the French transmission system operator, data centers connected to the transmission grid consumed close to 1 TWh in 2025, plus 3 TWh on Enedis's distribution grid in 2024. That is small compared with national consumption of 451 TWh. RTE expects between 21 and nearly 32 TWh in 2035 for data centers on dedicated sites, noting that those already connected use only 20% of the capacity they have reserved.
Do data centers use a lot of water in France?
Nobody knows precisely yet. The regulator Arcep measured 575,000 m³ withdrawn in 2024 by colocation operators, almost all of it drinking water, down 15% year on year. That scope excludes hyperscalers such as Amazon, Google or Microsoft, which will only enter Arcep's survey in 2027. The government cites a figure of 0.002% of the country's water withdrawals.
Is there a data center moratorium in France?
No. The government is instead speeding up large projects, with priority sites and a "project of major national interest" procedure. Several voices call for a pause: a National Assembly inquiry recommended in July 2026 a moratorium on non-European data centers, a draft resolution filed in October calls for a five-year moratorium on "non-sovereign" data centers, and groups such as France Nature Environnement demand an immediate moratorium. A Senate committee rejected the idea in a report adopted unanimously.
American voters asked a simple question: who pays for the electricity? France, which produces more power than it consumes, is asking a harder one: who benefits from these buildings, and who gets a say before they go up?
A French company that uses AI will not settle that debate, but it takes part in it every time it chooses a provider. Knowing where its models run, and for whom, is becoming a matter of continuity as much as principle.


